Skip to main content

McCullers Shoves and Altuve Slides: My Analysis of Game 1 of the ALDS

In previewing the ALDS, I wrote that the challenge for the Astros pitching staff was to “force contact…more contact on the mound means fewer walks.” 
 
Lance McCullers said “Challenge accepted.”
 
This afternoon at Minute Maid Park, Lance McCullers walked no White Sox, and allowed only 4 singles and one hit batter while going 6 2/3 innings. It is tempting to look at that line and say that McCullers pitched like an ace. But I look at his 4 strikeouts and 31% CSW (which is the percentage of pitches that were Called Strikes or Whiff), and see a performance that is not quite at ace level.  

Instead, I see a performance that was exactly what the Astros need to defeat the White Sox this series.

Lance's performance today was not marked by swing-and-miss stuff. He got 9 whiffs on his 104 pitches; that's an 8.7% swinging strike rate, below his season long rate of 11.6%. As noted, he only struck out 4 batters.  

What is was notable for was getting soft contact on balls on the ground. McCullers earned 11 of his 20 outs via groundout, including a double play off the bat of Yasmani Grandal in the 7th. The 19 batters who put balls in play against McCullers averaged a negative launch angle (-5.1) and an exit velocity of 83.4 miles per hour. Soft contact wins games, when you can get the other team to do it. 

As noted, McCullers did not walk a batter. But that is not because he threw more strikes. He threw 59.6% of his pitches today for strikes, which is below his regular season rate of 61.3%. But he threw strikes when he needed to. As Ben Clemens of Fangraphs pointed out in his article on today's game, McCullers "threw a grand total of 12 pitches in three-ball counts...All 12 were in the strike zone.  Clemens's conclusion: "He simply refused to give up a walk." 

The Astros have one of the best defenses in the majors, McCullers allowed that defense to make plays today by limiting baserunners and hard contact. Of the 19 balls put in play by the White Sox, the Astros recorded outs on 14 of them. The soft contact induced by McCullers meant that the Astros defense was not challenged to make difficult plays.

In his postgame press conference, McCullers said "I’m much more of a pitcher now than I was in the past."  That's a good assessment of McCullers' performance today

* * *

Winning postseason games are usually about doing the big things right. For example the team that hits more home runs during the season has an advantage because they usually hit more home runs in the playoffs.  And just as the Astros hit more home runs during the regular season than the White Sox, they also hit more home runs today, as Yordan Alvarez hit one into the Astros bullpen. 

But doing the little things can really help, as every play gets magnified in a short series. And one particular standout play was the slide by Jose Altuve to elude a tag by Yasmani Grandal and to score the Astros second run of the game. 

And I can analyze why it's a great play, but it seems like a much better idea to show you how people reacted to it. And you can decide which reaction was best?

Was it "poetry in motion?"

Or chef's kiss.

Or one of the best slides?  

Or perfect, and better in MLB's Field Vision 3D system? 

Or worthy of hanging in the Louvre? 

I'll let you decide what description you like best. It's an awesome slide. 

And more awesome because White Sox catcher Yasmani Grandal does not seem to be giving Altuve a lane to get to the plate. Altuve has to contort himself to avoid Grandal, which is no  longer supposed to be the case after rules on plate blocking (and knocking over the catcher) were changed before the 2014 season. 

So it's likely that Altuve would have been ruled safe regardless of the quality of his slide. But, getting that call right relies on a replay review from New York, and that's not something any of us want to rely on. And of course, Altuve's slide was definitely a much cooler way to score. 

 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

There's No Ace, but the Astros Rotation is Deep with Quality

  Who should the Astros start in Game 1 of a playoff series?  This question has come up a good bit recently. Jake Kaplan put that question as  the lead to his mailbag column  today. Radio talk show host Sean Pendergast asked the question in a weekend twitter poll.  #Penderpoll  … Astros starting pitcher in Game 1 of the playoffs (or a wild card game) … WHO YA GOT? VOTE: — Sean Pendergast (@SeanTPendergast)  August 14, 2021 I have three reactions to this question 1.) It's too early in the season to answer this question, even if we are getting to back half of August; there's still a lot of season to go. 2.) I'm sure that Dusty will go with McCullers; playoff experience will matter to him, and  3. This is a difficult question to answer because the Astros have a very unique starting rotation this season--one with lots of good pitchers but no ace. Taking a look at all American League pitchers by Wins Above Replacement, it's clear that the Astros have n...

Kendall Graveman's Improved Slider Has Made Him An Effective Reliever

Kendall Graveman is a different pitcher now.  I mean, he's an Astros today after being traded yesterday afternoon. The oddness of players being traded to the team they are playing was a major theme of yesterday's game, as Joe Smith and Abraham Toro played for the Mariners (and then presumably went back to the Astros team hotel...I'm pretty sure they were traded after check out time).  Graveman touched on his mixed set of emotions in a pre-game session with media from both Houston and Seattle.  An emotional Kendall Graveman was shocked to be traded from Mariners but excited for new opportunities with the Astros pic.twitter.com/3lVaMizuvs — Brian McTaggart (@brianmctaggart) July 28, 2021 But Kendall Graveman is a different pitcher in his pitch mix and approach this season. In particular, Graveman is throwing his slider  harder and more than ever.  Kendall Graveman in his new duds.  Graveman, who was part of the package Oakland received for Josh Donaldson...