Skip to main content

Dusty, Please Don't Use Jake Odorizzi the Third Time Through the Order

 One of the major analytic developments of my lifetime as a baseball fan has been the third time through the order penalty. First discussed in The Book: Playing the Percentages in Baseball by Tom Tango, Mitchell Lichtman, and Andrew Dolphin, the penalty is faced by pitchers who pitch against batters for the third time in a game. Starting pitchers do significantly worse their third time facing a hitter.

This season, major league starters give up an OPS of .701 their first time facing a hitter, then .743 the second time and .774 the third time. Batters are 6% worse than average their first time facing a pitcher, but 13% better the third time they face a starter.

This season, Jake Odorizzi has been hit particularly hard by the third time through the order penalty. His first time facing a batter, Odorizzi is giving up a slash line of .218/.293/.387 for an OPS of .680. His second time through the order, Odorizzi allows a slash line of .235/.307/.452, which is an OPS of .759.

But his third time through the order, it goes badly, very badly. Odorizzi allows opposing hitters to slash .387/.406/.903 for an OPS of 1.309. Over the course of the game, the average batter against Odorizzi goes from Jose Iglesias (.673 OPS this season) to Ramon Laureano (.760 OPS this season) to peak Barry Bonds. 

To give some context on Odorizzi's struggles the third time through the order, I created the table at the right. It shows this OPS against for all six of the Astros starters in the 2nd through 4th columns. 

You can see that each of the Astro starters this season have suffered from their own third time through the order issue. This is not surprising, as basically all pitchers receive this penalty over the course of their career. The surprise is Framber Valdez, who is defying the third time through the order this season, as his OPS against improves with each plate appearance. 

I also include columns at the right for tOPS and sOPS.  These are split numbers. tOPS compares each pitchers OPS the third time through the order to their own average.  As you can see, the other Astro starters give up an OPS 22% to 48% higher than their personal average when facing a batter for the third time. Again, Framber is the exception. 

sOPS compares an individual pitcher's split to the league average, which would be 100. This shows that most of the Astro starters perform better the third time through the order than the average MLB starters. Luis Garcia performs worse (114 means he's 14% worse than league average) and Framber's numbers the third time through the order stand out (45% better than league average). 

Odorizzi's numbers are really bad here. He gives up an OPS 132% worse than his own average and 126% worse than the average major league starter this season. When Odorizzi faces a batter for the 3rd time, it goes poorly. 

We saw this in his last start in Kansas City. And Odorizzi actually started out well in his 3rd time through the order, retiring Whit Merrifield and Nicky Lopez on pop ups in the bottom of the 4th, But in the bottom of the fifth, it started to get wobbly, as Salvador Perez lined out sharply for first and Carlos Santana blistered a ball 417 feet. Fortunately for Odorizzi, Santana hit the ball to straightaway centerfield and it only went for a double. An Andrew Benintendi ground out and a Ryan O'Hearn fly out kept the Royals at bay. Carlos Correa then hit a go-ahead home run to lead off the top of the 6th, and it looked like Jake Odorizzi might be credited with a win. 

But Dusty Baker decided to press his luck and sent Odorizzi out to start this 6th. Some noted observers first-guessed this decision.

And the decision blew up on Dusty, as the 8th place hitter Hunter Dozier not only hit the ball a long way like Santana, but managed to pull it over the bullpen for a long game tying home run.  Only then did Dusty pull Odorizzi.

Odorizzi's poor performance the third time through the order is partly a result of bad luck, and partly an issue of small sample size (he's faced only 32 batters the third time through in 10 starts where he's has faced a batter for the third time).  But mostly it is a talent issue. Odorizzi has fallen off as a pitcher this season. He's more vulnerable to hitters in general, but particularly when they have an advantage over him. 

The best strategy for Dusty Baker and the Astros to deal with the third time through the order penalty for Jake Odorizzi is to not accept the penalty. Today, Odorizzi will start for the Astros against the Mariners. The best strategy for the Astros is to remove Odorizzi before Mariners leadoff man J.P. Crawford bats for the third time today. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A House Divided: Mine

Baseball was at the beginning of our relationship. Shortly I moved to New York in 2007 to take a job as a professor at John Jay College, CUNY, one of my colleagues—a Red Sox fan—invited me to go to a Red Sox bar in the middle of Manhattan to watch Yankees- Red Sox. And Erin, another new professor in our political science department, was also a Red Sox fan, so she was going to come with. Sounds great. The first colleague got delayed, so Erin and I took the subway to the Red Sox bar, had a great time, had our first two beers and great conversation before our other colleague got there. Earlier that summer, I looked the schedule and found out that the Astros had a September series at Shea Stadium. I bought two tickets before I got to New York, figuring one of my new colleagues would want to join me at a ballgame.  And since the Red Sox fan was single, a woman, and into baseball, it seemed obvious to invite her. And by the 4 th inning, I knew I wanted to ask Erin out on a formal date. ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Is Jake Meyers for Real?

What's the greatest honor a player can win?  For Jose Altuve, it was the American League MVP Award. For Zack Greinke, it was the Cy Young Award.  And earlier today for Jake Meyers, it was the YouTube MVP award, given to the player of the game as voted on by fans watching the broadcast on YouTube. Meyers went 2 for 5, but his hard hit ball off of Royals reliever Joel Payamps brought home Alex Bregman for the walk-off 10th inning win.  Jake Meyers and His YouTube MVP Award. Meyers's good game today was not a fluke. He his now slashing .316/.344/.526 in 61 plate appearances since being called up from Sugar Land on August 1.  The Astros traded Myles Straw for Phil Maton because James Click thought that the combination of Chas McCormick and Meyers would produce as well as the combination of Straw and McCormick. So far, that component of the trade has worked as planned. Meyers has hit well, and McCormick has slashed  .333/.379/.467 in 66 plate appearances th...
Post a Comment
Read more